Back in March, when my school shut down, I bought into the "3 weeks to bend the curve". We didn't know what we were up against, possibly something as bad as the Black Death or the Spanish Flu. Stay home a couple weeks, let the hospitals ramp up, then get back to life as usual.
How naive I was--because I believed those in power.
I hope these vaccines work, because I don't know how much longer people will tolerate lockdowns that don't do anything good. We're told decisions are based on science! (said in best Thomas Dolby voice) but the evidence tells us otherwise.
Exhibit A:
San Mateo County, California, was one of the first jurisdictions in the
United States to fight the COVID-19 epidemic with sweeping restrictions
on social and economic activity. It joined
five other San Francisco Bay Area counties in issuing "shelter in
place" orders on March 16, three days before Gov. Gavin Newsom made
California the first state to impose
a COVID-19 lockdown. San Mateo County Health Officer Scott Morrow's
misgivings about reviving that policy are therefore especially striking.
"I'm not sure we know what we're doing," Morrow confesses in a
remarkable statement he posted on the San Mateo County health department's website this week.
It would be nice if more people in positions of responsibility were as honest.
Exhibit B:
So, a reporter from the Los Angeles Times
asked (California HHS Secretary Mark) Ghaly, “There have been some criticisms, including from the
Assistant Secretary of HHS, who said on Fox News, ‘I don’t know of any
data that says we need to shut down outdoor dining.’ I’m wondering if
you can respond to that?” Ghaly replied:
“As it relates to the question about indoor dining or
outdoor dining, I think one thing that I have tried to message and
emphasize is that right now we’re seeing such high levels of
transmission that…every activity that can be done differently and keep
us at our homes, not mixing with others, is safer. Those are going to be
the tools that help us get this under control.
“So the decision to include, among other sectors, outdoor dining, and
limiting that, turning to restaurants to deliver and provide takeout
options instead, really has to do with the goal of trying to keep people at home, not a comment on the relative safety of outdoor dining.
I've been saying it for awhile now: these lockdowns are about power, not about science!
Exhibit C:
California officials will allow playgrounds in the state to remain open following a backlash over a restrictive stay-at-home coronavirus order affecting parts of the state that have less than 15% intensive care unit-capacity in hospitals, according to reports...
“This kind of reversal on restrictions that have no data behind them,
that make no biologic sense, and that affect low-income groups
disproportionally is good governance and should keep on coming!" She
wrote in an email, according to the San Francisco Chronicle.
If science! were guiding the decisions, the playground rule wouldn't have been made in the first place. And if the playground rule was made based on science!, it wouldn't have been overturned just because people didn't like it.