Over at Joanne's blog are two posts about teaching math. First:
There's no evidence that "trauma-deformed pedagogy" (oops, "informed") helps students learn more, writes Max Eden, an American Enterprise Institute fellow, on Real Clear Education. Yet it's cited in support of California's controversial new math guidelines, which are full of dubious claims.
"Trauma informed" means educators take into account the fact that some students have led very difficult lives. But how does that affect teaching math...
The study includes no evidence students learned any math -- or that they "healed," writes Eden.
The examples cited would be a good social studies exercise, but they're crappy math. Let's continue:
Under the California framework, math teachers are supposed to train students to be change agents, writes Bill Evers of the Independent Institute. "The teacher is supposed to highlight 'connections' between math and 'environmental and social justice,'" perhaps by writing an “opinion piece” or “explanatory text.”
"Students who spent more time in class solving practice problems on their own and taking quizzes and tests tended to have higher scores in math," the study found. In English, "teachers who allocated more class time to discussions and group work ended up with higher scorers in that subject."
Teachers in both subjects spent little time lecturing.
Lifting weights is how you get stronger. Writing is how you become a better writer. Speaking a language is how you become better at a foreign language. Playing an instrument is how you get better at playing an instrument. It's funny that only in math do we throw such principles out, and we do it in the name of a "social justice" that accomplishes exactly the opposite of what its proponents claim they want.
Anyone who truly wants traditionally-underperforming students to succeed, and doesn't really want them to fail for their own political benefit, knows that the ideas contained in the new framework are a disaster, and it's not just those of us on the political right saying so:
Despite collapsing math scores, the California Board of Education
voted to adopt a new "equity'" and "social justice" focused math
education framework that education experts from across the political
spectrum warn will increase achievement gaps and decrease learning among
lower income and minority students.
Two out of three California
students now fail to meet basic state math standards set in 2013.
California spends over $20,000 per K-12 student, placing it among the
top states for per-pupil spending even though its students rank 30th in
math, according to national math SAT scores from the College Board.
Citing these differences, the framework focuses on three main changes
to improve "equitable" math outcomes: "an assets-based approach to
instruction; active student engagement through investigation and
connection; and instruction that centers cultural and personal
relevance, reflecting California's diverse students."
As I've stated before on this blog about so-called personal relevance:
According to one Kieran Egan,
“Bertrand Russell, after his first disastrous experiment in organizing a
school, observed that the first task of education is to destroy the
tyranny of the local and immediate over the child’s imagination."
Russell is correct. The purpose of education is to get a child to see what's beyond his own nose.
But let's continue with the linked article:
Additionally, the framework concluded that "five important components of
classroom instruction that can meet the needs of students who are
diverse in so many ways: 1) plan teaching around big ideas; 2) use open,
engaging tasks; 3) teach towards social justice; 4) invite student
questions and conjectures; 5) prioritize reasoning and justification."
I'll be happy to "teach towards social justice", but I doubt what I teach would be what the framework's authors and promoters would want.
I'll be blunt. As Instapundit has said many times: If they can't give you good government, they'll give you "woke" government. I'll add to that: If they can't give you good education, they'll give you "woke" education. And that's exactly what California is dishing up here.
"Progressive" educators will never admit they believe some students just aren't smart enough to learn algebra, Smith writes. But it's "impossible to avoid the conclusion that the idea is to make all kids equal by making them equally unable to learn."
People in the average IQ band or higher can learn algebra. Those who are well below average perhaps are unable to understand algebra's abstractions--but we in the schools shouldn't toss them aside as unteachable. We should teach them something different, and not pretend we're preparing them to attend a university.
Bringing everyone down to the lowest level is the end result of "equity". We should do better than that.
The California State Board of Education voted to adopt a new—and
much-debated—math framework on Wednesday, concluding a years-long
process that involved three drafts, prompted hundreds of suggested
revisions, and reignited decades-old arguments over the purpose of math
education and the meaning of equity.
The 1,000-page framework aims
to put meaning-making at the center of the math classroom, promoting a
focus on problem-solving and applying math knowledge to real-world
situations. It also encourages teachers to make math culturally relevant
and accessible for all students, especially students of color who have
been traditionally marginalized in the subject.
“The United States
has not been teaching math effectively or equitably. We are one of the
lower-achieving countries … and California is below the national average
in its achievement in mathematics,” said Linda Darling-Hammond, the
president of the California State Board of Education, during the board’s
meeting on Wednesday. “This is an area of great need, and change is
imperative. The same old, same old will not get us to a new place.”
Here are all my posts referencing Darling-Hammond, stretching back almost 15 years.
Should you ever wonder why I question if I'll make it 4 more years till retirement, this is why.
One crucial section of the framework
emphasizes teaching “for equity and engagement” and encourages math
educators to adopt a perspective of “teaching toward social justice.”
The CDE and SBE suggest that cultivating “culturally responsive”
lessons, which highlight the contributions of historically marginalized
individuals to mathematics, can help accomplish this goal. The guidance
further advocates for avoiding a single-minded focus on one way of
thinking or one correct answer.
Critics argue that the proposed framework does not prioritize
academic achievement. Angela Morabito, a spokesperson for the Defense of
Freedom Institute (DFI), stated, “Despite what the proponents of this
plan might say, it’s not really designed to boost academic achievement.
It’s designed to further a progressive goal that exists in the minds of
adults… The math framework really does show misplaced priorities.”
The CDE and SBE acknowledge that math proficiency has been waning
across the state, with less than one third of students meeting or
exceeding grade-level expectations during the 2021-22 academic year.
Data provided by the departments reveals widening achievement gaps, with
math proficiency among Black students more than 30 percentage points
below that of their White counterparts.
California’s incoming community colleges chancellor, Sonya
Christians, doesn’t officially step into her new role until June 1, but
she has an urgent agenda: enrolling every ninth grader in a college
course.
Right now, just 6% of California students take a college course through dual enrollment
in their first year of high school. The time is now, Christian said, to
make sure that all 436,192 of the state’s eighth graders will be
automatically enrolled in a college course next fall.
“Can we do this? We must. We must,” Christian said. “We can’t wait for tomorrow.”
Christian made this urgent call to action earlier this month at the first Dual Enrollment Equity Conference,
an event that brought 450 dual enrollment advocates and educators from
California’s K-12 and college systems to Bakersfield. What she calls her
“ninth grade strategy” is emblematic of the type of work she expects to
push during her tenure as the next chancellor.
If a 9th grader can take and pass a college course, the course is probably too easy to be considered a college-level course. Of course, those who preach equity equity equity don't think black and brown skinned kids can compete academically with white and Asian kids, which is why they want standards lowered.
If you live in California, your electricity bill could be affected by how much money you earn.
California's
three largest power companies - Southern California Edison, Pacific Gas
& Electric, and San Diego Gas & Electric - have submitted a
joint proposal to the Public Utilities Commission outlining a fixed rate
restructuring that would be based on one's income.
The plan
would break down monthly bills into the fixed rate plus a reduced usage
charge based on consumption. According to officials this fixed-rate plan
would reduce monthly bills for low-income customers and if electricity
usage is controlled, bills would also be lowered.
I'm sure there's some so-called social justice aspect to this. I should pay more than a 20-something because I make more than a 20-something? I've already been a 20-something and worked to earn more, and now I do. Are we going to do the same for gas, groceries, insurance? Will I have to submit 1040s to corporations now?
Just another example of how the left doesn't want to bring anyone up, it wants to bring everyone down to the lowest common denominator.
A faculty director of the Office of Equity, Social Justice and Multicultural Education at De Anza College in Cupertino, California, says her contract was not renewed after she questioned the school’s so-called “anti-racism” policies. The diversity director, a black woman, added that she experienced “hostility, harassment, and bullying” after speaking out.
Dr. Tabia Lee told Inside Higher Ed that her contract is being terminated after she questioned antiracist “orthodoxy,” objected to the college’s land acknowledgments for an Indigenous tribe, and tried to bring a “Jewish inclusion” event to campus.
Lee added that additional reasons for her contract not being renewed by the college included her declining to join a “socialist network,” refusing to use the terms “Latinx” and “Filipinx,” and inquiring why the word “black” was capitalized but not “white.”
The former diversity director, who is black, added that an employee in her diversity office accused her of “white speaking,” “whitesplaining,” and supporting white supremacy.
So-called land acknowledgements are my favorite: those people used to live here, but it's ours now, and no, we're not going to give it back. That's essentially what every so-called land acknowledgement says! But back to Dr. Lee:
“People have literally attacked me just for doing what I always taught
my students to do, which is to think critically, to respect diverse
opinions and viewpoints, and to exercise their own freedom of
expression,” she added.
I respect her opinion.
Anyone want to place bets on whether she gets her job back eventually?
I spent some time a few nights ago running through Indeed.com looking at different jobs. I came to one conclusion: I'm unemployable.
For years my dream job has been to work at a gaming company, one that designs and manufactures slot machines, running the calculations for slot machine wins--a Game Mathematician. Most of the entry-level jobs seek a "recent college graduate", and the more advanced positions require skills I don't have. I'm in no man's land, probably a common experience for people of a certain age.
There are many analytical-type jobs, often in health care, and there are also the education jobs (specifically community college). Those jobs require a submission not only of a resume, but also of a statement of support for minorities, members of underserved communities, the disabled, the sexual minorities, English learners, etc. Here's an excerpt:
Candidates must exhibit an appreciation of, a sensitivity to, and a
respect for a diverse academic environment, inclusive of students,
faculty, and staff varying social, economic, cultural, ideological and
ethnic backgrounds.
Some of them are even more declarative.
We believe that educational justice can only be achieved when all
students are successful — including students of color, students from
low-income communities, English learners, and students with
disabilities. Our team is committed to addressing gaps in educator
understanding and practice, pairing support with high expectations,
allowing all students the opportunity to access high-quality
instruction.
Educational "justice"? How about "excellence"? If you're using "woke" terms like "educational justice", you're not interested in high expectations, you have ideological goals that don't align with academic excellence, despite claiming otherwise.
To be honest, I don't care about your social, economic, cultural, ideological, or ethnic background. If you're in my class, I'm going to teach you math. If there is a difficulty, we'll see what other resources are available to help me to teach and you to learn. I'm interested in my students as students, not as members of groups that don't have any relation to learning math. You want so-called educational justice? Seek academic excellence, and justice and success will follow.
You can say I'm old-fashioned, and I am, but tell me, how are your "woke" views working out? Is student achievement going up? Is there any evidence that high school students are doing better than in the recent past, or that university students are graduating better prepared to succeed in the adult world? The reason so many jobs require university degrees is because high school diplomas are worthless, a point I've made several times on this blog. A university degree today is only slightly more valuable than a high school degree of the past.
No, I don't fit the political or ideological structures in education today, and I'm too honest to lie in a statement of ideological conformity. Thus, until I find a position that is not directly related to teaching math, I'm sort of stuck where I am. Five more years, I should be able to make it.
The Left's racial hatred and the racial climate it creates produces these outcomes:
Student-run debate organizations at Northeastern University and Boston College co-hosted the American Parliamentary Debate Association’s (APDA) “inaugural BIPOC tournament” and explicitly prohibited white students from competing.
The BIPOC (Black, Indigenous, and people of color,) only tournament included teams from multiple universities including the University of Chicago.
As The Chicago Thinkerreported
this past semester, The University of Chicago informed students the
BIPOC debate was only open to anyone who “does not identify as white"...
Topics for the debate tournament include “issues relating to race and social justice"...
According to Northeastern University’s Policy and Procedures,
"Northeastern University strictly prohibits discrimination or
harassment on the basis of race, color, religion, religious creed,
genetic information, sex, gender identity, sexual orientation, age,
national origin, ancestry, veteran, or disability status."
Similarly, Boston College’s University Notice on Nondiscrimination explicitly
prohibits discrimination based on race, stating “federal laws and
regulations require the University not to discriminate on the basis of
race, color, national origin, disability, sex, or age in treatment,
employment, admission or access to Boston College and its educational
programs and activities."
When asked to
clarify how the debate’s exclusion of white students would not infringe
this policy, neither Northeastern University, Boston College, the
Northeastern Debate Society, nor event organizers responded.
California's racist and anti-achievement math framework from last year has been cleaned up a little, but systemic problems remain:
The proposed California Mathematics Framework
generated a storm of controversy when the first draft was released in
early 2021. Critics objected to the document’s condemnation of tracking
and negative portrayal of acceleration for high-achieving students.
Indignation focused on the recommendation that schools stop offering
Algebra I to mathematically precocious eighth graders. A revised draft
was released in 2022, softening the harsh language of the original text
while leaving intact the framework’s dim view of course acceleration or
other forms of tracking.
Those are important issues; however, this
post is concerned with students on the opposite end of the distribution
of achievement: students who struggle with math. Over the past decade,
math scores on the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP)
have been declining at the 25th percentile, indicating that
struggling students are falling even further behind their peers.
Moreover, as schools recover from the pandemic, the percentage of
students with disappointing math achievement is sure to go up. What does
the framework portend for them? What evidence does the framework rely
upon to build its recommendations for these vulnerable youngsters...
It appears that the framework’s ideological commitment to the
principle that all students should be treated the same—same curriculum,
same instruction—is the primary reason why the extensive literature on
struggling students is ignored. Effective interventions require
identifying students who are falling behind and creating supplemental
instructional settings for them, either in small groups or individually.
In contrast, the framework places all its bets on instruction that
attends to mindset theory, lessons using math to explore social justice
topics, and Universal Design for Learning (UDL) to reduce the number of
students who need extra help. The framework doesn’t say it out loud, but
the idea that students could fall behind once this instructional regime
is established is treated as unlikely.
The framework’s second
ideological commitment is to inquiry. Topics are organized around “big
ideas” and “drivers of investigation.” Inquiry methods have a
century-long checkered history,
particularly for struggling students in the primary grades. As a long
time reader of California’s frameworks, I can say that the 2022 Math
Framework is the most inquiry-oriented that I’ve seen since the 1992
California Math Framework. This statement from the 1992 framework
could have easily come from the 2022 version: “Children often
misinterpret and misapply arithmetic and algebraic procedures taught the
traditional way. This program, in contrast, values developing number
and symbol sense over mastering specific computational procedures and
manipulations.” The 1992 framework flew under the radar until a
coalition of concerned parents and mathematicians, in what became known
as “The Math Wars,” rallied against the textbooks and instructional
methods that the framework spawned and drove them all out of state
policy...
The 2022 California Math Framework does not reflect current
scholarship on how to serve students who struggle when learning
mathematics. A search of studies cited in a recent What Works
Clearinghouse publication, “Assisting Students Struggling with
Mathematics: Intervention in the Elementary Grades,” reveals absolutely
no overlap. None of the studies cited in “Struggling Math Students” are
cited in the framework. This is particularly troubling because of the
transparent, rigorous process followed in producing the practice guide,
ensuring that recommendations are based on scientifically sound
research. In sharp contrast, the process employed to search literature
and select evidence for the framework’s recommendations is unknown. It
is not described in the document or on the framework’s website.
The
California State School Board will consider the framework for adoption
in July, 2022. All students will be poorly served if the state endorses
inquiry over explicit instruction. Students who dream of pursuing a STEM
major will arrive at college unprepared.
Students who have difficulty learning math will see their frustrations
increase and challenges multiply as they fall further behind their
peers.
Barrington, Rhode Island,
public schools are among the best in the state. Many parents move to
the district, and tolerate the higher taxes, because of the academic
rigor that sets their children up for attending Ivy League schools or
receiving academic merit scholarships. However, all of that academic
appeal is being chipped away after the district brought in a so-called
"equity and inclusion" agenda.
De-leveling, or a
system of universal learning, was first implemented in Barrington on
the most vulnerable students—the students with learning disabilities and
Individualized Education Programs (IEP). In February 2020, in the midst
of the COVID-19 pandemic,
the school removed some conceptual classes. On the whole, parents of
children in those classes were reluctant to speak out because they ran
the risk of "outing" their child as having a disability or needing
special accommodation...
Rage broke loose among parents of all political stripes after the honors
students were targeted, parents said. The school announced that the
days of honors English and social studies were gone. Parents protested,
arguing that the move deprived their children of a competitive edge –
and in effect – future opportunities such as merit scholarships...
Bill Jacobson, a long-time Barrington resident and founder of Legal
Insurrection, said, "De-leveling is part of an agenda of equalizing
outcomes. This equal-results approach stems from critical race theory and
diversity, equity and inclusion, which posit that unequal outcomes are
the result of systemic bias and discrimination. ‘Equity’ in particular
is the codeword for bringing high achievers down to equalize outcomes,"
Jacobson said. "'Equity' has become an unhealthy obsession, and parents
are seeing the impact."
They've given up trying to raise certain students to high standards, so instead they want to lower the rest of the students to lower standards. "Equity" is the rhetoric of jealousy and failure.
Today our collaboration time was spent in focus groups for our accreditation visit by the Western Association of Schools and Colleges next year.
I don't know how we were assigned to these focus groups, but mine involved school culture and "equity". Seriously, do you think I am going to contribute to anything that WASC (or our school administration) is looking for regarding equity?
They could have put me in a focus group regarding testing and assessment, or something else academic. But I assure you, the vast majority of my colleagues--all California educators, remember--not only do not agree with my views on culture and "equity", they have no interest in even hearing such views. That meeting today was an hour of my life I'll never get back, and there are plenty more such meetings planned over the next year.
I have officially moved into the "old curmudgeon" column, sitting out my time until retirement. I'm not going to throw any wrenches into the pipes, but since I have nothing to offer in the field of culture and "equity", I am not going to assist in a process that I think is severely wrongheaded. I will be neutral, doing no more than is absolutely required of me, and letting the true believers do the heavy lifting. In 25 years of teaching I've done plenty of the heavy lifting for those things I thought were important, now I guess it's someone else's turn.
Let those who care do the work in this focus group. I don't give a duck.
Update, 4/9/22: Just prior to this past week's meetings I was moved from the Culture Club to the testing/assessment group.
Fossil fuels are the best technology we (currently) have for transportation, and nuclear is the best we have for electricity production--and not-so-surprisingly, the greenies are against both. It's hard not to believe that they're watermelons, green on the outside and red on the inside. Even people who just feeeeeel that wind and solar are the way to go aren't really thinking about the reality:
Climate policies promoted and imposed by Team Biden and Democrats are
based on junk science, headline-grabbing scare stories, and computer
models that create far-fetched “scenarios” asserting that fossil fuel
use and emissions will cause Earth to warm by 4 degrees C (7 F)over the next 80 years, and cause Arctic warming that will bring colder winters.
Those dire predictions are used to justify more taxpayer-funded
“research,” like a recent Columbia University “mortality cost of carbon”
study that claims 83 million people
(the population of Germany) “could be killed” this century by those
rising planetary temperatures. Therefore we must take “immediate action”
to “transform” our energy and economic systems, and replace oil, gas
and coal with (millions of) wind turbines and (billions of) solar panels
and backup batteries.
These policies are lethal for people and planet They would require mining on scales unprecedented in human history, much of it by slave and child
laborers, and nearly all using fossil fuels – bringing massive habitat
and wildlife losses, air and water pollution, and horrific human health
and safety problems.
But since most of the mining, ore processing and manufacturing will
occur in other countries, far from the USA, politicians and climateers
can say this “alternative energy” is “clean and green.”
Worse, climate policies cause widespread “energy poverty” – energy
prices rising above families’ ability to stay adequately warm (or cool)
at reasonable cost, given their incomes. That means peopledie.
Let's not forget that cold kills a lot more people each year than heat does.
And let's just state the obvious:
Job destruction, energy poverty, illness and deaths would increase
dramatically under anti-fossil-fuel policies mandated and imposed by the
Biden Administration and fellow Democrats – in the name of fairness,
equity and “climate justice.”
If you're not in favor of nuclear energy, you're not serious about reducing so-called greenhouse gases.
The author of this piece solicited my input but I didn't see or respond to her email until the I got home from work, which was too late. Still, I think she did pretty good!
According to California's draft "Mathematics Framework," math is not
just a "neutral discipline"; it also can be used to promote equity and
"social justice."
Call it "Woke Math."
The authors mean well. They want to close the achievement gap between
white and Black and Latino students. But they're doing it the wrong
way. They're trying to close the gap by pretending that math -- a
discrete discipline forged on the purity of numbers -- can be taught
like English or political science.
If California approves the framework, expect it to be a guide for textbooks used across the land. This is what it looks like.
It was shelved until next year--but they'll try it again next year.
Supporters of a Natomas Unified School District teacher filmed in an undercover video discussing antifa called for the district to allow the teacher to return to his position during a Wednesday news conference at the Sacramento office of civil rights attorney Mark Merin.
Natomas Unified has announced they plan to fire the Inderkum High School teacher, Gabriel Gipe, after a conservative group, Project Veritas, filmed him and published an edited 12-minute video of him sharing how he wants his students to become revolutionaries...
“After an investigation, Mr. Gipe was recommended for termination because he had violated many policies, Ed Code, and more,” read a statement from Natomas Unified. “As we shared, there are nearly 400 pages of charges and evidence. Mr. Gipe was actively teaching pro-communism ideology in a US Government class.”
The district said Gipe “was clearly representing his school and district” during the recorded conversation. His termination must be approved by the board of trustees...
Merin, who is not officially representing Gipe, said the district moved forward with its decision without due process.
“How is it that a school board can jump to a conclusion and announce a disciplinary job action against a fantastic teacher who is extolled by his students without the minimum due process that is enshrined in our state constitution, our federal constitution, and in the contract that teachers have with their school board?” Merin said.
I call BS here. I have no doubt that Comrade Gipe was provided due process. What it looks like he wasn't provided is what I call undue process, the purpose of which is to make eliminating the commie so difficult that the district just acquiesces.
The linked article goes on to identify several people speaking in support of Comrade Gipe. This one, though, wins the idiot prize:
Sonia Lewis, a community activist who works with several school districts in the area, said teachers across the country are afraid of losing their jobs for speaking the truth in history classes.
“And that truth is simply the history of those who have been left out of Black and brown and indigenous, API, Latinx, LGBTQ, Muslim communities all over this country,” Lewis said. “Having taught social studies in this state, knowing the standards that are required to make sure that information is disseminated based on the information on standards and curriculum, I know for sure that revolution is change and it is positive.”
No one in California is afraid of losing his/her teaching job due to speaking in favor of the groups Ms. Lewis mentions. No one. Let me wear a MAGA hat to school one day (on Hat Day, no less) and let the complaints roll in. BTW, I almost never wear hats, certainly not to school, and I wore that one only because it was a gift from a student.
Anyway, here's what I have to say to Comrade Lewis:
I spent the first several years of my adulthood training to kill commies, I'm not going to brook their nonsense now.
Societies set standards for a host of reasons, though two are
primary. First, standards, whether civil or legal, allow us to measure
objective reality. For instance, the purpose of standards, such as
school grading, is to identify the relative skill of people in a
particular endeavor–with the endeavor in schools being the ability to
read, write, and reason. Second, and flowing from the first, standards
allow us to identify those people who excel in that skill set and
promote them and, as a corollary, to find and help those who fail to
meet the standard. Moreover, the effectiveness of particular efforts can
be assessed.
Everything in the above paragraph is either antithetical to, and
under direct attack from, progressive leftists. They have no desire to
identify objective reality. They have no desire for a meritocracy.
They have no desire to assess the effectiveness of any efforts they
embrace to address supposed problems. Their goal is not to benefit
society by upholding a meritocracy or, at the other end of the scale, to
help those they claim to want to help. Instead, they simply want
permanent political power in this country. Everything else is
secondary. And to accomplish their real goal, they invoke the charge of
“systemic racism” to attack standards and the facts that inform those
standards.
I've heard critical race theory described as a religion, complete with original (white) sin but without grace:
Critical race theory proponents, who have infiltrated nearly every
aspect of our culture, would say that no one could blame Baucham if he’d
ended up jobless, homeless, or in prison. The movement—which sorts all
humans according to their immutable characteristics and ranks them in
hierarchies of oppression or victimhood—would claim that Baucham was
born a victim simply by virtue of his skin color.
Instead, he became a standout Division I football player and went on
to earn a pile of degrees that space does not permit me to list. He’s
written scores of books, pastored a church, and is currently dean of the
School of Divinity at African Christian University in Zambia. His new
book, Fault Lines: The Social Justice Movement and Evangelicalism’s Looming Catastrophe (Salem/Regnery),
is not only a repudiation of Marxist critical justice theory, but also a
warning to the church about the growing divide between two Christian
camps: one that relies wholly on scripture as a source of truth, and a
second that relies on a dangerous, unbiblical ideology—one that Baucham
calls a cult (more on that in a moment).
Baucham defines and explains critical justice theory—a broader term
that encompasses more than just race—by prodigiously citing the writings
of its proponents, using an earthquake as a metaphor for the “seismic
shifts in the evangelical landscape,” a fault line, if you will. From
the very first chapter of this excellent book—a must-read for anyone who
wants to understand critical justice theory—Baucham insists that ethnic
tensions are not the problem, nor are political divisions. Rather, the
problem is social justice versus biblical justice, the former being “incompatible with biblical Christianity"...
“My heart is broken as I watch movements and ideologies against which
I have fought and warned for decades become entrenched at the highest
and most respected levels of evangelicalism,” he adds. “I want this book
to be a clarion call. I want to unmask the ideology of Critical Theory,
Critical Race Theory, and Intersectionality in hopes that those who
have imbibed can have the blinders removed from their eyes, and those
who have bowed in the face of it can stand up, take courage, and
‘contend for the faith that was once for all delivered fo the saints’
(Jude 3).”
Christians must “identify, resist, and repudiate” these dangerous
ideas. “We cannot be held hostage through emotional blackmail and
name-calling.” Instead, the church should heed Colossians 2:8: “See to
it that no one takes you captive by philosophy and empty deceit,
according to human traditions, according to the elemental spirits of the
world, and not according to Christ"...
Baucham calls CSJ (critical social justice) a “new religion” with “many of the hallmarks of a
cult.” Several years ago he coined the term “ethnic gnosticism,” which
he defines as “the idea that people have special knowledge based solely
on their ethnicity,” which results in a “single black perspective,” the
notion that white people cannot “see” without black voices, and the
belief that “narrative” trumps truth.
The Bible, insists Baucham, flies in the face of ethnic gnosticism:
“The very idea of dividing people by ethnicity, then declaring some of
them wicked oppressors and others the oppressed, is inconsistent with
the biblical doctrine of universal guilt” described in Romans 3: “None
is righteous, no, not one; no one understands; no one seeks God. All
have turned aside; together they have become worthless; no one does
good, not even one.”
Sin “is not the state of white men; it is the state of all men,”
Baucham says. Ultimately, the current CSJ movement is a “covert attack
on the sufficiency of Scripture"...
“I oppose BLM and have refused to even say the phrase. Moreover, I think
the movement (and by extension the phrase) is a Trojan horse that poses
a clear threat to the witness of the Church… The movement has a name
that Christians find attractive because we love God and our neighbor and
have a desire to see justice done. And for some, that has come to mean
embracing the false narrative of ‘state-sponsored terror against black
and brown bodies' "...
“One of the biggest problems with antiracism is the fact that it is
law-based. It condemns based on melanin, and although it constantly uses
the words, it holds out no hope of salvation, restoration, or
reconciliation. Because antiracism is law-based, its ultimate end is
changing and establishing laws, then enforcing those laws
authoritatively.”
Antiracism “is powerless against racism,” he insists. “It is Christ
and Christ alone, ‘who has made us both one and has broken down in his
flesh the dividing wall of hostility (Ephesians 2:14),” he says. “This
doesn’t mean that black and white Christians won’t offend or sin against
each other. It also doesn’t mean that the sin of racism will not raise
its ugly head in the broader culture, or even in the Church. What it
does mean is that we have an answer"...
“The most powerful weapon in our arsenal is not calling for reparations:
it is forgiveness. Antiracism knows nothing of forgiveness because it
knows nothing of the Gospel. Instead, antiracism offers endless penance,
judgment, and fear.” Baucham urges Christians to “love your brothers
and sisters enough to contend with them and for them.”
The article is so good that I just keep excerpting and excerpting. Read the whole thing.
Update, 6/19/21: Here's an 18-minute history and summary of critical race theory. Arm yourself with this knowledge.
The first thing to understand about this movement is that it rejects
the basic values of the civil rights movement. Martin Luther King called
for the equal rights of minorities, and he dreamed of a day when black
people would “not be judged by the color of their skin but by the
content of their character.”
In contrast to MLK, as I argue in the article, social justice
activists don’t want to end discrimination. They don’t want people
judged only on the basis of merit and character. They don’t want to
replace racial strife with racial harmony. They don’t seek reform,
progress, or justice; they seek subversion, disruption, and collective, identity-based retribution.
. . . Social justice activists want individuals purged for questioning
BLM, purged for defending law enforcement, purged for saying “all lives
matter,” purged for supporting peaceful protests over riots. They call
for abolishing the police. They defend rioting and looting (or commit it
themselves). They block, harass, and shut down speakers. They
reflexively slander their adversaries as racists, fascists, Nazis,
misogynists, or white supremacists.
One can understand why Critical Race Theory’s proponents would seek
to link it to the civil rights movement, which properly enjoys a
hallowed status in American history—and which yielded some of the most
revered and intensely studied Supreme Court judgments on law-school
curricula. But this line of argument, however rhetorically attractive,
is logically incorrect: Critical Race Theory (often abbreviated as CRT)
explicitly undermines the intellectual and moral foundations of
color-blind American liberalism.
The civil rights movement was based on a hopeful and optimistic
vision of modern Americans turning the country’s ideals into reality.
CRT, on the other hand, presents a dystopian vision in which ubiquitous
bigotry and oppression defines America’s national soul. Far from being
heir to the civil rights legacy, Critical Race Theory is in many ways
its opposite.
It's a hateful philosophy put forward by hateful people. It has nothing in common with the Civil Rights Movement of the 50s and 60s.
My previous post on the proposed California math framework focused on Chapter 2. I did that because I wanted to emphasize the race-based nature of the document.
That's not the only thing wrong with the framework, though. Chapter 1, the introduction to the framework, should be subtitled An Assault on Excellence. It seems that the philosophy is "if everyone can't excel, no one can." We'd never impose such a philosophy on something important--like sports--but math? No problem, tear it down.
In a recent post, education blogger Joanne Jacobs wrote:
Once, California insisted that schools teach algebra in eighth grade in
the name of equity: All students would have access to classes leading to
12th-grade calculus and careers in science, technology, engineering and
math (STEM).
The state’s proposed mathematics framework, which may be ratified this summer, would delay algebra till high school and calculus till college.
Putting all math students in the slow lane
will hurt high achievers without helping anyone else, argues Bill Evers
of the Independent Institute, a former U.S. assistant secretary of
Education, in the Wall Street Journal.
California's 1997 math standards had 8th grade students take Algebra 1 so they could be ready to
take calculus in high school; this was done in the name of equity. Today,
keeping students out of calculus in high school is proposed in the name
of equity. Which version of equity has the best interests of students in
mind?
The word calculus is used 23 times in this chapter, just about all of them
disparagingly. The first few pages of the proposed framework dive into
so-called social justice--and why calculus in high school is bad.
"Calculus" is a stand-in for "excellence". Page 16 refers to a "rush to calculus" and also quotes from an MAA/NCTM joint statement:
the ultimate goal of the K-12 mathematics curriculum should not be to get students into and through a course in calculus by twelfth grade but to have established the mathematical foundation that will enable students to pursue whatever course of study interests them when they get to college.
It should be antithetical for those of us in education to hold students back from learning as much as they can. But holding back students in pursuit of a political goal is exactly what this proposed framework does. We should be providing the best education possible to all of our students, not punishing top performers because of the skin color of most of those top performers. We should establish a strong mathematical foundation and allow students to accelerate to calculus. It's possible in other countries, it's possible in other states--why only in California is achievement to be looked down upon?
"[S]tudents do not do well when rushed through mathematics courses", we read on p. 16. I agree with that. On the other hand, though, there's a difference between accelerating and rushing, and we should be doing the former for those who are capable of learning at a faster rate.
It gets worse on p. 17, where we read:
All students can take Common Core-aligned mathematics 6, 7, and 8 in middle school and still take calculus, data science, statistics, or other high-level courses in high school.
How? If all students are to take the same classes in middle school, with no option of acceleration, then high school offers Integrated Math 1/Algebra 1, IM2/Geometry, IM3/Algebra 2, and then a pre-calculus/trig course. How do they get to calculus, where do they accelerate? Won't they have to rush?
This framework doesn't change the math standards (Common Core) at all, it merely focuses educators on race. Does anyone truly believe that keeping students together in the same middle school math classes, not allowing any student to accelerate in math until high school, is going to improve math education?
When they get to high school, students will still be encumbered. Page 6 tells us:
...changing the high-school level mathematics remains a critical component to opening mathematics doorways for all students.
Page 8 tells us:
A fundamental aim of this framework is to respond to issues of inequity in mathematics learning.
The framework seems fixated on the achievement gap, but its poor attempt at a solution reminds me of this exchange:
"He'd rather the poor were poorer, provided the rich were less rich." The authors of this framework are ok with a smaller achievement gap, even if their means of doing so only penalizes the top students and does nothing for the lowest students. (You do yourself a grave disservice if you don't watch the full 2:33, as Mrs. Thatcher even describes the gap.)
Chapter 1 opens by telling us that "mathematics has a history of exclusion and filtering, rather than inclusion and welcome...Girls and Black and Brown children, notably, represent groups that more often receive messages that they are not capable of high-level mathematics, compared to their White and male counterparts...." Shortly thereafter we encounter the term "Latinx", a term that even NPR tells us only 3% of US Latino adults use. This is not a balanced document; it was written by far-left-leaning people for whom race, not math, is the priority, and it will be imposed on your children, not theirs. It's filled with the same old prescriptions--discovery learning! culturally-responsive math! investigations! open-ended questions! no right or wrong answers!--that have long been proposed by "fuzzy math" advocates but that only harm students.
The new 2021 Mathematics Framework, currently under consideration by California’s Department of Education, does away
“with all tracking, acceleration, gifted programs, or any instruction
that involves clustering by individual differences, without expressing
any awareness of the impact these drastic alterations would have in
preparing STEM-ready candidates.” Readjustments in this direction are
happening in other states, too.
These measures will not only hinder the progress of the generations of
our future STEM workforce but also contribute to structural
inequalities, as they are uniquely detrimental to students whose parents
cannot send them to private schools or effective enrichment programs.
Children stuck with this low-quality education are rarely prepared for
higher education and employment in STEM.
These are just a few examples of an unprecedented fervor for revolutionary change in the name of Critical Race Theory (CRT),
a doctrine that views the world as a fierce battleground for the
narratives of various identity groups. This will only lead to a further
widening of racial disparities in educational outcomes while lowering
American children’s rankings in education internationally.
The suggestions in this framework should not be taken seriously by anyone who wants to improve math education.
I never thought I'd see the day when racism is so close to being injected into math instruction. People of good conscience must put a stop to it here and now. I thought I'd end this post with some applicable quotes--some attributed, some not--and ask you to consider them as you ponder the impact of this proposed document:
When they can't give you good government, they give you "woke" government. When they can't give you good education, they give you "woke" education.
It is the end game of their ideology. Norms divide, so all norms must
be oppressive. All norms must be destroyed. ... it’s not all norms. It’s
all higher values. That’s even worse. And I believe these are the
direct targets: quality itself, competence itself, excellence itself.
—Jordan B Peterson
Wokeness is a weapon of privilege. Wokeness is not really about fairness for minorities, the oppressed and the poor, past or present. It is mostly a self-confessional cult of anointed bullies, and hypocrites of all races and genders, who seek to flex, and increase, their own privilege and power. Period.
—Victor David Hansen
Wokeness is the state religion of the oligarchs. Wokeness is not about taking power from The Man. Wokeness is The Man’s way of securing his power over the rest of us.
—Glenn Reynolds
The allure of being a powerful victim is too great for most humans to deny. It’s seductive because it’s easy. Victimhood undermines principles of hard work & self-discipline & replaces them with entitlement & blame. The power is an illusion and the price is our agency.
—Bridget Phetasy
Update, 5/29/21: Here's a good analysis of the proposed framework. Read the whole thing:
Rooted in Profound Anti-intellectualism, Elitism, Racial and Gender Prejudice, the 2021 CMF Threatens to Undermine Math Learning for All Students and Leave Disadvantaged Ones Permanently Behind.