Monday, May 14, 2018

At Michigan, It's Not the 21st Century. It's 1984.

Even the most ardent leftist must be able to recognize that this is a bad idea, shouldn't they?
Don’t be surprised if what I am about to describe sounds like a scene out of George Orwell’s 1984, where the Thought Police would arrest any citizen criticizing the regime or otherwise disagreeing with the official view on everything from politics to culture. And they used surveillance that included informers and electronic devices like cameras and microphones.

That is what the University of Michigan has been transformed into -- the equivalent of Oceania in 1984 or the former East Germany. As the lawsuit says, the university has created an “elaborate investigatory and disciplinary apparatus to suppress and punish speech other students deem ‘demeaning,’ ‘bothersome,’ or ‘hurtful’.” Yes, really: The student disciplinary code defines “harassment” as any “unwanted negative attention perceived as intimidating, demeaning, or bothersome to an individual” (emphasis added).

In other words, as the complaint says, “the most sensitive student on campus effectively dictates the terms under which others may speak.” Under this absurd but dangerous policy, a student expressing his positive opinion about Donald Trump could be considered “bothersome” to the many (or any of the) liberal students on campus...

This speech code violates fundamental First Amendment rights to speak freely, and will have a profoundly chilling effect on students and faculty -- assuming there are any faculty members at Michigan who stand out from the liberal academic hierarchy that runs most campuses these days like the Inner Party in Oceania.

The university has its version of the Stasi and Orwell’s Thought Police -- a “Bias Response Team” that investigates supposed “bias” complaints from offended students -- students who can file their complaints anonymously. So if you are accused of wrongdoing, you don’t even have a right to confront your accuser -- just like the former citizens of East Germany where the Stasi had literally hundreds of thousands of informers who could be your next-door neighbor or even a member of your own family. Or in this case, a student down the hall or from one of your classes.

If you think this Star Chamber process is limited to verbal speech, think again. Just like the electronic surveillance in Oceania, the “Bias Incident Report Log” posted by Michigan on its website shows that the Bias Response Team may come after you for what you do and say in “On-line/Social Media” communications including texts, emails, and Twitter.

The log also shows that the campus secret police -- sorry, the Bias Response Team -- also goes after “Off Campus” speech. So students aren’t safe anywhere. Their First Amendment rights are severely restricted, no matter what they are doing or where they are.

So a student may literally receive a knock on his door “from a team of University officials threatening to refer the student to formal disciplinary authorities” for something some unknown, anonymous informant alleges that he said, something the informant doesn’t like, or doesn’t agree with, or is uncomfortable with. Unless, of course, as the complaint says, the student agrees to submit “to ‘restorative justice,’ ‘individual education,’ or ‘unconscious bias training’.”
The movie The Lives of Others dragged a bit much for my taste, but I'm told it's a rather accurate portrayal of the depths the Stasi plumbed in order to spy on their own citizens.  Tell me how it's all that different from what you read above.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

This is completely off topic, but do you have a math curriculum you would recommend for junior high/high school. The school district is currently using CPM, which is terrible. A group of parents are getting together to request a change.

Darren said...

Saxon. or Singapore.