Sue and Wil are my classmates from West Point. West Point cadets at that time were divided into 36 companies of 100+ cadets who lived and ate together and roomed in the same barracks, and Sue and I were in the same company from the beginning of our sophomore year till her departure at the end of our junior year. I knew of Wil, knew who he was, but didn't really know him at all. Wil was not in our company.
I read Sue's 2013 blog posts accusing Wil of rape and was saddened by what I read.
Based on the details I read in those blog posts, I know whose story I found more credible. I don't know if a rape occurred or not. Almost thirty years after the fact I don't know how a determination could be made one way or the other. This wasn't a rape case, though, it was a defamation case, and the jury decided fairly quickly whom they believed.
This is just a sad situation all around. The last four years have been a black mark on our class.
And for a variety of reasons, I'm not going to say publicly which one of them I believed more.